Discover the Best Tasting Black Coffee

Last Updated on February 22, 2024

For those of us who love a good cup of coffee, there is nothing quite like the simplicity and purity of a perfectly brewed black coffee. That will always, always get my vote. But what makes black coffee the “best”?

Is it the depth of the flavor, the texture, or the aroma that makes it so enjoyable?

best tasting black coffee

In this blog post, we’ll be exploring all the different facets of black coffee, from its health benefits to the most effective brewing methods. Along the way, we’ll introduce you to our top picks for the best-tasting black coffee, and we’ll explain why they’re better than anything else out there.

So, whether you’re a seasoned black coffee aficionado or you’re just getting started on your journey to discover coffee to drink black, you’re sure to find something interesting and informative within the pages of this post. So, sit back, relax, and let’s get started!

By the way, if you click on a link and then decide to make a purchase, we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. Thank you!

Black Coffee Defined

Black coffee is much more than just a caffeine delivery system. It’s a beverage enjoyed around the world for its rich flavor and energizing boost.

What sets black coffee apart from other coffee-based options is the simple fact that there is nothing else added to it. No cream, no sugar, just the pure essence of coffee roasted to perfection and brewed to bring out its bold and complex flavors.

Some may argue that adding sweeteners or dairy products enhance the coffee-drinking experience, but purists insist that black coffee is the only true way to experience the full spectrum of flavors in a fresh cup of Joe.

Benefits of Drinking Our Coffee Black

benefits of drinking our coffee black

For coffee lovers, the brewing process is a sacred ritual, and that final drop of steaming black coffee is nothing short of enchanting. But have you ever considered the benefits of drinking black coffee? If you’re used to adding sugar, cream, or flavored syrups to your cuppa joe, it’s time to switch to the dark side.

First and foremost, when you drink black coffee, it is the healthiest way to enjoy this beloved beverage. Besides being free of added sugar and calories (Keto friendly!), black coffee is teeming with antioxidants that support your immune system and neutralize harmful molecules in your body.

whiskey barrel coffee gift

Antioxidants are compounds that help protect our cells from damage caused by harmful molecules called free radicals, which can lead to inflammation, aging, and a range of illnesses. And black coffee happens to be one of the richest sources of antioxidants in the Western diet.

Some of the potent antioxidant compounds found in coffee include chlorogenic acid, polyphenols, and melanoidins. Drinking a cup or two of black coffee each day could help support your immune system, reduce your risk for chronic diseases, and help you feel more alert and focused. 

Intermittent Fasting and Black Coffee

Drinking coffee black and intermittent fasting have more in common than you might think. Both have gained a significant following in recent years for their benefits to overall health and wellness.

Intermittent fasting, which involves limiting your food intake to a specific window of time each day, has been shown to improve digestion, boost your metabolism, and even increase lifespan.

Meanwhile, black coffee has been praised for its ability to enhance mental focus and alertness, as well as support weight loss efforts. When combined, these two practices can be a powerful tool in achieving your health goals.

By drinking black coffee during your fasting window, you can help suppress hunger and stay energized throughout the day.

Best Tasting Black Coffee

best tasting coffee brands for brewing black coffee

This is what gets my vote, and I’ve been a black coffee drinker since the age of twelve. I won’t mention how many years exactly that is, but suffice it to say that I’ve got years of experience.

I have found these brands to have the best coffee to drink with the best overall flavor profile. Note that I like my coffee strong, so most of my recommendations are for a dark roast. But, I’ve included a couple of medium roast options for those of you who aren’t ready for the deep richness of the dark side.

While light roast coffee has its place, my recommendations include richer, deeper flavors.


Peets Major Dickason’s

Peets Coffee Major Dickason dark roast

Looking for a bold, rich coffee that packs a punch? Look no further than Peet’s Coffee’s Major Dickason’s Roast! This highly popular dark roast is beloved by coffee connoisseurs for its deep, complex flavor profile that hits all the right notes.

With tasting notes that range from dark chocolate and smoky oak to subtle citrus and floral undertones, Major Dickason’s Roast is truly a coffee lover’s dream come true. And with its full-bodied, slightly sweet finish, this coffee is sure to leave you feeling satisfied and energized all day long.

Starbucks Sumatra

Starbucks Sumatra blend

Starbucks Sumatra blend coffee is a fan favorite among coffee drinkers worldwide. This particular blend is known for its robust flavor and earthy undertones, making it the perfect choice for those who prefer a bold and complex taste. Its availability in various packaging options, including ground coffee, whole bean, and coffee pods, make it easy to indulge in this delightful brew at home or on the go.

What truly sets the Sumatra blend apart, though, is its unique source – the Sumatra island in Indonesia. The coffee beans are grown in the lush rainforest region and handpicked by local farmers, ensuring that every cup supports sustainable and ethical farming practices.

Green Mountain Dark Magic

If you’re on the hunt for a bold coffee that’s sure to wake you up and get you going, Green Mountain Brand Coffee’s Dark Magic roast is just what you need. This rich, full-bodied blend boasts a uniquely complex flavor profile that’s sure to satisfy even the most discerning of coffee connoisseurs. But what makes it so popular among coffee drinkers?

For starters, it’s made with only high-quality Arabica beans sourced from some of the best coffee-growing regions in the world. The beans are then slow-roasted in small batches to perfection, resulting in a smooth and creamy finish with just the right touch of sweetness. Plus, with its sustainable and eco-friendly practices, you can feel good knowing that you’re supporting a company that’s committed to doing its part in protecting the planet.

Altruistic Joe Smokehouse

Altruistic Joe Smokehouse Dark Roast coffee

Altruistic Joe is more than just a coffee brand; it’s a philosophy. The company’s mission is centered around ethical and fair trade practices, with a focus on supporting independent coffee farmers in developing countries. Altruistic Joe’s dedication to quality and sustainability is evident in their Smokehouse dark roast coffee, which is bold, rich, and full-bodied.

Made from a blend of organic, shade-grown beans from Central and South America and roasted to perfection, this coffee has notes of cocoa, dark cherry, and a hint smoky flavor that will leave you wanting more. Altruistic Joe not only cares about the taste of their coffee but also about the impact it has on the world. By choosing to support this socially responsible, Veteran-owned brand, you’re not just getting great coffee, you’re making a difference in the lives of the people who produce it. Read my review here

Bean Box Dark Side of the Moon

Bean Box Dark Side of the Moon coffee

Bean Box is a coffee brand committed to the idea that coffee should be an experience. They offer a variety of roasts, brewing methods, and blends, all with the goal of bringing people together over a great cup of coffee. Their philosophy revolves around making each step of the coffee journey—from sourcing to brewing—excellent and sustainable.

One of my favorites is the Dark Side of the Moon medium-dark roast coffee. Crafted by artists from Blossom Roasters, this coffee brings a deep, complex flavor to your morning cup. With notes of chocolate, nuts, and caramel, it’s a coffee that satisfies both coffee aficionados and casual drinkers alike.


Tim Horton’s Original Blend

Tim Horton's Original Blend coffee

For coffee connoisseurs, Tim Horton’s is a brand that needs no introduction. And for good reason! Tim Horton’s coffee boasts a rich and smooth taste that coffee drinkers love. In fact, it’s no surprise that the brand’s medium roast blend is so popular among coffee enthusiasts and casual drinkers alike. I’m a picky coffee snob and I enjoy a cup of Tim Horton’s K-cup coffee quite regularly. Yes, I surprised myself. 🙂

Its distinctive aroma and flavor profile makes it a sought-after blend for those seeking an energizing morning boost. Plus, the convenience of purchasing Tim Horton’s coffee from grocery stores means that fans of the brand can enjoy it from the comfort of their own homes. So, whether you’re looking to kickstart your day or simply enjoy a delicious cup of coffee, Tim Horton’s medium roast coffee is definitely worth a try!

Atlas Coffee Club

Atlas Coffee Club now offers K cups

Looking for a coffee brand that values sustainability and ethical sourcing practices? Look no further than Atlas Coffee Club. This company prides itself on its commitment to fair trade, direct trade, and single-origin coffee beans. Every batch of coffee is roasted fresh and shipped directly to your doorstep, giving you the ultimate coffee experience. They offer a fun, educational, and very tasty coffee club membership, with the opportunity to try coffees from around the world. Read my review here.

Their medium-dark roasts, which offers a bold and rich flavor profile. But the best part? Each bag of coffee comes with information about the coffee’s origin, so you can learn about the farmers who grew the beans and the unique flavors of their region. Try Atlas Coffee Club for a delicious and conscious coffee experience.

How to Brew the Best Tasting Black Coffee: A Complete Guide

guide to brewing the best tasting black coffee

There’s nothing like the aroma of good coffee brewing in the morning. For many coffee lovers, a cup of coffee is essential to kickstart their day. Brewing coffee may seem like a simple process, but there’s a little more to it than you might think.

A good cup of coffee requires attention to detail, precision, and a little bit of love. Here are some tips and tricks on how to brew the best tasting black coffee. From the right brewing method to the choice of coffee roast, and using filtered water. So, grab your favorite mug and let’s get brewing!

Brewing Methods:

There are several ways to brew coffee, but the method you choose has a significant impact on the taste. The most common methods are drip coffee makers, pour-over coffee makers, French press, espresso, and cold brew.

If you want the smoothest and purest cup of black coffee, then the pour-over method is the way to go in my opinion. Its slow and precise process extracts the coffee’s full flavor and aroma.

Coffee Roast:

The type of coffee roast you choose also affects the taste. There are three types of coffee roasts- light, medium, and dark. Light roasts have a fruity and acidic flavor, medium roasts have a balanced flavor with hints of caramel, and dark roasts have a bold and rich flavor.

If you want a smooth and less bitter taste, then choose a medium roast, especially if you are new to the coffee-drinking world.

Freshly Ground Coffee Beans:

It’s always better to grind your coffee beans just before brewing. This ensures maximum freshness and flavor. Pre-ground coffee beans lose their aroma and flavor quickly.

Invest in a burr grinder to grind your coffee beans to a consistent grind size, ensuring an even extraction. They are budget-friendly for most.

Filtered Water:

The quality of water used to brew coffee is essential. Water that contains minerals affects the coffee taste. Filtered water ensures that the coffee’s flavor profile is not altered by any unwanted substances.

Avoid using tap water or distilled water as it lacks the necessary minerals to enhance the coffee’s flavor.

Pour-Over Method:

Step 1

First, grind your coffee beans (unless you are using pre-ground coffee). Measure out 4 tablespoons – not heaping – of coffee beans and grind them to a medium – medium/fine level.

If you have a grinder with settings, you’re all set. If your coffee grinder is like mine and doesn’t have settings, it’s a timing thing. You might have to experiment a little bit, but for me, it’s a 12 second count to the perfect grind. 

Like I said, this is a simple and unscientific method, my friend.

Step 2

Place a filter in your coffee dripper and put the ground coffee in the filter. Some folks say that if you wet the filter before adding the coffee it helps to keep it in place. Give that a go if you like.

Tap the dripper a time or two, to even out the grounds.

Place the dripper over your coffee cup or mug.

Step 3

Now, heat your water. It’s best to use filtered water because you’ll most likely get the truest, cleanest coffee taste. Again, experiment and see what type of water gives you the best result.

If you’re using an electric kettle, set it to 195 or 200 degrees and wait for it to heat. You can heat up to 205 degrees but don’t go higher than that for optimal taste and extraction.

Are you heating water on the stove? No worries. Let it just come to a boil, take the water off the heat and let it sit for 30-45 seconds, then go to the next step.

If you want to be certain that you’re using the right amount of water, pour 10 ounces into a measuring cup. Once you become accustomed to brewing with the pour over method you’ll be able to eyeball it and can skip the measuring cup.

Step 4

Now we are going to let the coffee ‘bloom’. Pour just enough water over the grounds to cover them, then wait for the water to drip through. It will take about 30 seconds or so.

A lovely benefit of the blooming process is that you get to enjoy the aroma of the coffee as the carbon dioxide is being released. 

Step 5

Pour more of the water in the dripper, starting from the outside edge and going in a circular motion toward the middle. Stop when the dripper is getting full, and wait for the coffee to drip through to the cup.

One more pour should use up the remaining water. The entire pour over process will take about 3 minutes.

And yes, it’s a bit of a ritual once you get the hang of it. I really enjoy the process, and somehow it makes the coffee taste that much better!

It’s worth the effort to enjoy a cup of coffee that’s smooth and rich in aroma and flavor. Experiment with different brewing methods, roast types, and grind sizes until you find the perfect cup. Remember, there’s no one-size-fits-all when it comes to brewing coffee, so don’t be afraid to try new things.


What is the best way to brew black coffee?

The pour-over method is considered by many to be the best way to get the most flavor and aroma out of your beans. It’s slow and precise process extracts all of the flavors, resulting in a smooth cup of black coffee.

What type coffee roast should I use?

For a smooth and less bitter taste, choose a medium roast if you’re just starting to experience drinking your coffee black. Light roasts have a fruity flavor, while dark roasts have a bold and robust flavor.

How do I grind my coffee beans?

Invest in a burr grinder to ensure a consistent grind size, and grind your beans just before brewing. This ensures maximum freshness and flavor.

What kind of water should I use?

Avoid using tap or distilled water as it lacks minerals that enhances the coffee’s flavor. Instead, invest in filtered water for a better tasting cup of black coffee.

What is the best temperature for brewing coffee?

You’ll have the most success with water that is between 195-205 degrees Fahrenheit.

Is drinking black coffee healthy?

Black coffee is a source of antioxidants and can also boost your metabolism. However, too much caffeine can lead to side effects like insomnia, headaches, and anxiety. Therefore, it’s best to limit your daily intake of black coffee to 1-2 cups per day, or monitor your body’s reaction to the coffee and decide what works best for you!


Brewing the best-tasting black coffee requires some knowledge of coffee roasts (hopefully you’ve gleaned that right here!), patience, and attention to detail.

From choosing your brewing method, selecting your preferred roast, grinding freshly ground beans, and filtered water, each step matters.

It’s worth the effort to experience a cup of coffee that is full of flavor and aroma. Take some time to experiment with different roasts, grind sizes, and brewing methods. Don’t forget to limit your intake of black coffee to 1-2 cups per day for a healthier lifestyle. Enjoy!

Best Tasting Black Coffee - which to try, how to brew, and more!